Listen to I Want You to Be My Girl online. I Want You to Be My Girl is an English language song and is sung by Frankie Lymon and The Teenagers. I Want You to Be My Girl, from the album Save the last dance for me - 200 R&B Hits (The Greatest Rhythm & Blues Classics of the 50s & 60s), was released in the year 2017. The duration of the song is 2:56. Download English songs online from JioSaavn.